Serving Austin, Lake Travis & Central Texas Divorce · Custody · Support · Guardianship  |  (254) 408-8794

Contested Guardianship in Austin

Not every guardianship is a family effort. Siblings may disagree about who should serve, a parent may insist they do not need help, or someone may be accused of misusing money. When a guardianship is contested, the case looks more like a trial. Here is how these disputes work in Texas and how to protect the person at the center of them.

Bluebonnets at the Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center in Austin

What Makes a Guardianship Contested

A guardianship becomes contested when someone with standing files an objection, a competing application, or otherwise asks the court to rule against what the applicant wants. Contests usually fall into a few patterns:

  • Is a guardianship needed at all? The proposed ward, or a relative, argues the person still has capacity or that less restrictive tools will work.
  • Who should serve? Two siblings each want to be guardian, or a second spouse and adult children from a first marriage both apply.
  • How much power? One side wants a full guardianship; the other wants a limited one that preserves more rights.
  • Misconduct claims. One relative accuses another of financial exploitation, isolating the parent, or misusing a power of attorney.
  • Removal. After appointment, someone asks the court to remove the guardian for failing to perform their duties.

Each type of dispute calls for a different strategy and different evidence. The common thread is that the court's focus stays on the proposed ward's well-being, not on which relative wins.

Who Can Contest

Texas law generally allows any person to contest a guardianship application, with an important exception: a person who has an interest adverse to the proposed ward cannot file an application or contest one. For example, someone suing the proposed ward or claiming the proposed ward's property may be shut out. Courts look at the specific facts, and standing challenges are common early fights in contested cases.

The proposed ward always has a voice. The court appoints an attorney ad litem to represent them, and that attorney is required to advocate for the proposed ward's wishes and rights. If your mother says she does not want a guardian, her attorney will tell the court that, even if her children disagree. In some cases the court also appoints a guardian ad litem, who looks at what is in the proposed ward's interest and reports to the court.

Lake Travis, west of Austin
Lake Travis, west of Austin

The Evidence That Matters

Because the applicant must prove incapacity by clear and convincing evidence under Texas Estates Code §1101.101, contested cases often turn on medical proof. The physician's certificate of medical examination is the starting point, but in a contest each side may present:

  • Testimony from treating physicians, neurologists, or geriatric psychiatrists.
  • An independent medical examination requested by a party or ordered by the court.
  • Bank statements and records showing how money has been handled.
  • Testimony from caregivers, neighbors, friends, and staff at a facility.
  • Prior estate-planning documents, such as powers of attorney or a declaration of guardian.
  • The court investigator's report and the attorney ad litem's position.

If the dispute is about who should serve, the evidence shifts to suitability: each candidate's relationship with the proposed ward, history of handling money, ability to provide care, any conflicts of interest, and whether anyone is disqualified under Texas Estates Code §1104.351. A written declaration in which the proposed ward named or disqualified a guardian can carry significant weight.

Keep your own records clean. If you have helped a parent with money, gather receipts and statements now. In a contest, the relative who can document every dollar is in a much stronger position than one who cannot.

Mediation, Jury Trials, and Hearings

Many contested guardianships settle. Mediation lets family members work out who will serve, which powers are needed, and how information will be shared, with help from a neutral mediator. Agreements might include a limited guardianship, co-guardians, a professional guardian of the estate with a family member as guardian of the person, or regular accountings to siblings. The Travis County Probate Courts may encourage or order mediation in contested matters; check current court practices for details.

If the case does not settle, it goes to a contested hearing. The proposed ward has the right to request a jury trial in a guardianship case. Most cases are decided by the judge, but the option exists and can change strategy. In a temporary guardianship, contests are heard on a faster schedule; see our page on temporary guardianship.

Costs and Who Pays

Contested guardianships can be expensive, and a hard truth is that fees are often paid from the ward's estate, which means the money the family is fighting to protect. The court may approve reasonable fees for the attorney ad litem, a guardian ad litem, and in some circumstances the applicant's attorney. A court can also order costs paid by a party who acted in bad faith or without just cause.

That reality is one of the strongest reasons to look for an agreement. Spending a parent's savings on a court fight in Austin may leave less for memory care or in-home help. We help clients weigh the cost of a contest against what is truly at stake.

Contests Involving Second Marriages and Blended Families

Blended families produce many of the hardest guardianship disputes. A father in Lakeway remarries late in life; when his health declines, his new wife and his adult children each want control. Spouses generally have priority to serve, but priority is not automatic if the court finds the spouse unsuitable. These cases can overlap with questions about community property and estate planning. If a divorce is also on the table, our page on gray divorce may be relevant, and note that a guardian's authority over a ward's divorce raises its own complex issues.

Downtown Austin lit up at night
Downtown Austin lit up at night

When You Are Defending Against a Guardianship

Sometimes our client is the person facing guardianship, or a relative who believes the person can still manage with support. A defense often focuses on:

  • Showing capacity in specific areas through medical evidence and testimony.
  • Putting alternatives in place, such as a durable power of attorney or a supported decision-making agreement, if the person still has capacity to sign them. See alternatives to guardianship.
  • Narrowing the guardianship so the person keeps rights like voting, driving, or choosing where to live.
  • Challenging the applicant's suitability or standing.

Even after a guardianship is granted, a ward can later seek restoration or modification if their condition improves.

Where These Cases Are Heard

Travis County contested guardianships are heard in the Travis County Probate Courts, Probate Court No. 1 or No. 2, which are separate from the family district courts. If the proposed ward lives in Williamson or Hays County, the case is filed and heard in that county. See our page on Williamson and Hays County courts. Disputes about which county is proper can themselves become part of a contest, especially when a parent has recently moved.

Talk With Our Team Before the Conflict Grows

Family disputes over guardianship can damage relationships for years. Our team helps clients across Central Texas, from Spicewood to Manor, present strong evidence, explore settlement, and keep the focus on the person who needs protection. Call (254) 408-8794 or reach us through our contact page. You can also review the guardianship process to understand the steps ahead.

Frequently asked questions

Can my parent refuse a guardianship?

Your parent can object, and their court-appointed attorney ad litem must present that objection. The court then decides based on the evidence whether a guardianship is needed and how broad it should be.

Can there be a jury in a Texas guardianship case?

Yes. A jury trial can be requested in a guardianship proceeding, though many cases are decided by the judge or resolved by agreement.

Who pays the lawyers in a contested guardianship?

Reasonable fees are often paid from the ward's estate with court approval, though the court can shift costs to a party who acted in bad faith or without just cause.

Can my sibling and I serve together?

Texas courts can appoint co-guardians in some situations, or split roles so one sibling is guardian of the person and the other is guardian of the estate.

Can a guardian be removed if they are not doing the job?

Yes. An interested person can ask the court to remove a guardian for reasons such as misusing funds, failing to file required reports, or neglecting the ward.

Talk with an Austin divorce and family law attorney

Every family's situation is different. Tell us what's happening and we'll walk you through your options under Texas law and how your case would move through the Travis County courts.

Call (254) 408-8794